- Seven Islands
- Seven Stars
- Seven Stars
- Sewaren
- Sewell
- Shacks Corner
- Shad Island
- Shady Lawn Manor
- Shark River Hills
- Shark River Island
- Sharon
- Sharp
- Sharper
- Sharps Corner
- Sharptown
- Shaw Island
- Shawcrest
- Shaws Mill
- Shaytown
- Shell Pile
- Shell Pile
- Shellbed Landing
- Shelter Island
- Shelter Island
- Sheppards Mill
- Sherbrook Estates
- Sherwood West
- Shiloh
- Shinntown
- Ship Bottom