- Shambaugh Siding
- Shamrock Lakes
- Shanghai
- Shannondale
- Sharon
- Sharpsville
- Sharptown
- Shawswick
- Shedville
- Sheff
- Sheffield Estates
- Shelburn
- Shelburne
- Shelby
- Shelbyville
- Shepardsville
- Shepherd
- Sheridan
- Sherwood Forest
- Shideler
- Shields
- Shiloh
- Shipshewana
- Shirkieville
- Shirley
- Shoals
- Shoals Overlook
- Shooters Hill
- Shore Acres
- Shorewood Forest