- Phenita Island
- Philadelphia
- Philipse Manor
- Phillips Creek
- Phillips Mills
- Phillipsburg
- Phillipsport
- Philmont
- Philwold
- Phoenicia
- Phoenix
- Phoenix Mills
- Pickettville
- Picnic Island
- Picnic Island
- Picton Island
- Picture Book Mobile Home Park
- Piercefield
- Pierceville
- Piermont
- Pierrepont
- Pierrepont Manor
- Pierstown
- Piffard
- Pike
- Pike Island
- Pikes Corner
- Pikeville
- Pilgrim Corners
- Pilgrimport